Current Male Pilgrims
| Pilgrims' Name | Church |
| Jim Anderson | Bethany/Spencer |
| Bruce Beecher | Congregational/Spencer |
| Vint "Butch" Bellows | First Lutheran Church/Milford |
| Mark Bennett | Carroll, IA |
| Michael Bryan | Bethany, Spencer |
| Mark Hopkins | Bethany Lutheran Church |
| David Hopkins | Bethany Lutheran Church |
| Duane Kent | St. Paul Lutheran/Aurelia |
| Allen Klumper | Bethany Lutheran Church |
| Steve Kracht | Bethlehem, Royal |
| David Larsen | Bethany Lutheran Church |
| Greg Lear | Bethany/Spencer |
| Gene Michel | Presbyterian/Cherokee |
| Edward Peterson | Bethany, Spencer |
| Nick Poolman | 1st Presbyterian/Spirit Lake |
| Rodney Quanbeck | First Lutheran Church |
| Tom Vanderwoude | Good News Spirit Lake, IA |
| Ryan Waltner | Abiding Saviour Tea, SD |
| Seann Wheeler | Vineyard Comm./Waverly |
Current Female Pilgrims
| Pilgrims' Name | Church |
| Sharon Anderson | Bethany/Spencer |
| Kim Aneweer | Spirit Lake |
| Shirley Baker | Wallingford |
| Sandi Beecher | First Congregational/Spencer |
| Pam Bellows | First Lutheran Church/Milford |
| Joan Bennett | Carroll, IA |
| Joann Booth | Estherville, IA |
| Jackie Bryan | Bethany, Spencer |
| Patricia Cowan | All Saints Episcopal |
| Lyn Creswell | Spirit Lake |
| Stacey DeWerff | Storm Lake |
| Kelli Farrar Larsen | Bethany Lutheran Church |
| Jamie Hansen | Spencer |
| Lucille Kent | St. Paul Lutheran/Aurelia |
| Linda Klein | Turning Point Milford |
| Kristi Kracht | Bethlehem, Royal |
| Ann Lear | Bethany, Spencer |
| Donna Michel | Presbyterian/Cherokee |
| April Mueller | 1st Presbyterian/Spirit Lake |
| Tami Mugge | Bethlehem, Royal |
| Lauri Odor | First Congregational/Spencer |
| Amy Peterson | Bethany, Spencer |
| Merry Peterson | Trinity Lutheran,Cherokee |
| Crystal Quanbeck | 1st Lutheran/Milford |
| Mary Riepke | First Lutheran Church/Milford |
| Pam Thee | First Lutheran Church/Milford |
| Jana Volkert | Washta |
| Sarah Waltner | Abiding Saviour Tea, SD |
| Lorraine Westfall | Humboldt |
Past Male Pilgrims
| Year | Pilgrims' Name | Church |
| 2007 | Larry Niemeier | Cherokee |
| 2007 | Ron Seaman | Emmetsbug |
| 2007 | Steve Olson | Bethany - Spencer |
| 2007 | John Mast | Storm Lake |
| 2007 | Mark Jensen | Everly |
| 2007 | Frank Hirschman | Kingsley |
| 2007 | Joey Struefert | Bethany - Spencer |
| 2007 | Ray Mortensen | Alta |
| 2007 | George Kruger | Bethany - spencer |
| 2007 | Dan Yonker | Jackson, MN |
| 2006 | Wally Tschopp | Hartley |
| 2006 | Curt Berkland | Bethany - Spencer |
| 2006 | Kevin Neuhaus | West Okoboji |
| 2006 | Tim Christensen | Royal |
| 2006 | Bill Ridout | Estherville |
| 2006 | Ed VerSteeg | Spencer |
| 2006 | Dennis Weeks | Worthington, MN |
| 2006 | Shannon Bauer | Hope Reformed - Spencer |
| 2006 | Aaron McHone | Spencer |
| 2006 | Tom James | Storm Lake |
| 2006 | Terri Nobles | Holstein |
| 2006 | Pat Reasons | Okoboji |
| 2006 | Dale Cline | Cherokee |
| 2006 | Michael Schrunk | Spirit Lake |
| 2006 | Nathaniel Meyer | Spencer |
| 2006 | Harold Westberg | Armstrong |
| 2006 | Lynn Meier | Manson |
| 2005 | Pastor Craig ZumBrunnen | Cherokee |
| 2005 | Dennis Koelling | Milford |
| 2005 | Allan Holmen | Arnolds Park |
| 2005 | Brian Luepke | Spirit Lake |
| 2005 | Andre Frigo | Milford |
| 2005 | Jim Anderson | Storm Lake |
| 2005 | Bryan Baumhover | Storm Lake |
| 2005 | Troy McKinney | Bethany - Spencer |
| 2005 | Gary Book | Garner |
| 2005 | Ray Ellerbusch | Holstein |
| 2005 | Jeff Baker | Spirit Lake |
| 2005 | Pastor Mike Thiel | Estherville |
| 2005 | Greg Manwarren | Bethany - Spencer |
| 2005 | Karl Brandt | Bethany - Spencer |
| 2005 | Bob Moore | Milford |
| 2005 | Kurt Weeks | Hope Reformed - Spencer |
| 2005 | Dale Magnusson | Hope Reformed - Spencer |
| 2005 | Philip Bernier | Ocheyedan |
| 2005 | Ryan Blau | Hope Reformed - Spencer |
Past Female Pilgrims
| Year | Pilgrims' Name | Church |
| 2007 | Jean Olson | Bethany - Spencer |
| 2007 | Gayle Mast | Storm Lake |
| 2007 | Jen Jensen | Everly |
| 2007 | Jenny Hirschman | Kingsley |
| 2007 | Brindi Utemark | Nebraska |
| 2007 | Roberta Bochtler | Storm Lake |
| 2007 | Ellen Heine | Bethany - Spencer |
| 2007 | Carolyn Kruger | Bethany - Spencer |
| 2006 | Becky Tschopp | Hartley |
| 2006 | Lisa Berkland | Bethany - Spencer |
| 2006 | Lyda Neuhaus | West Okoboji |
| 2006 | Lynn Rhoads | Cherokee |
| 2006 | Margaret Stangohr | Storm Lake |
| 2006 | Susan Christensen | Royal |
| 2006 | Marie Weeks | Worthington, MN |
| 2006 | Mary Jo Meier | Manson |
| 2006 | Molly McHone | Spencer |
| 2006 | Sharon Lindemann | Bethany - Spencer |
| 2006 | Michelle VerSteeg | Spencer |
| 2006 | Amanda Hoffmann | Spencer |
| 2006 | Cynthia Bauer | Hope Reformed - spencer |
| 2006 | Cindy James | Storm Lake |
| 2006 | Lyann Burns | Spirit Lake |
| 2006 | Caryl Cline | Cherokee |
| 2006 | Sharon Schrunk | Spirit Lake |
| 2006 | Grace Westberg | Armstrong |
| 2006 | Susan Meyer | Spencer |
| 2005 | Lynne Koelling | Milford |
| 2005 | Sharon Holmes | Arnolds Park |
| 2005 | Delores ZumBrunnen | Cherokee |
| 2005 | Debra Jones | Milford |
| 2005 | Sheri Luepke | Spirit Lake |
| 2005 | Marjorie Roberts | Milford |
| 2005 | Sally Anderson | Storm Lake |
| 2005 | Leann Baumhover | Storm Lake |
| 2005 | Kim McKinney | Bethany - spencer |
| 2005 | DeeDee McCoy | Spirit Lake |
| 2005 | Geri Bruning | Holstein |
| 2005 | JoAnn Tapper | Cherokee |
| 2005 | Pastor Susan Stone | Estherville |
| 2005 | Gayle Schmeling | Emmetsburg |
| 2005 | Kim Weeks | Hope Reformed - Spencer |
| 2005 | Kim Ford | Spencer |
| 2005 | Michelle McLaury | Bondurant |
| 2005 | Tara Ford | Milford |
| 2005 | Annesley Gunderson | Spirit Lake |
| 2005 | Beth Magnusson | Hope Reformed |
| 2005 | Wynette Moore | Milford |
| 2005 | Sharon Womack | Webster City |
| 2005 | Kati Nelson | Aurelia |
| 2005 | Pat Vician | Emmetsburg |
| 2005 | Amy Blau | Hope Reformed - Spencer |
